| Click here to view overtime games by conference |
| Click here to view overtime games by number of overtimes |
| Year: 2009 | Thru: 11/21/09 |
| Team | Conference | Opponent | Date | Score | Number of overtimes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Air Force | Mountain West | Navy | 03-OCT-09 | 13-16 | 1 |
| Air Force | Mountain West | Utah | 24-OCT-09 | 16-23 | 1 |
| Arizona | Pacific-10 | Oregon | 21-NOV-09 | 41-44 | 2 |
| Army | FBS Independent | Vanderbilt | 10-OCT-09 | 16-13 | 1 |
| Boston College | Atlantic Coast | Wake Forest | 26-SEP-09 | 27-24 | 1 |
| Buffalo | Mid-American | Western Mich. | 24-OCT-09 | 31-34 | 1 |
| Clemson | Atlantic Coast | Miami (FL) | 24-OCT-09 | 40-37 | 1 |
| Connecticut | Big East | Notre Dame | 21-NOV-09 | 33-30 | 2 |
| FIU | Sun Belt | La.-Lafayette | 31-OCT-09 | 20-17 | 1 |
| Fresno St. | Western Athletic | Wisconsin | 12-SEP-09 | 31-34 | 2 |
| Georgia Tech | Atlantic Coast | Wake Forest | 07-NOV-09 | 30-27 | 1 |
| Hawaii | Western Athletic | San Jose St. | 21-NOV-09 | 17-10 | 1 |
| Iowa | Big Ten | Ohio St. | 14-NOV-09 | 24-27 | 1 |
| La.-Lafayette | Sun Belt | FIU | 31-OCT-09 | 17-20 | 1 |
| Maryland | Atlantic Coast | James Madison | 12-SEP-09 | 38-35 | 1 |
| Miami (FL) | Atlantic Coast | Clemson | 24-OCT-09 | 37-40 | 1 |
| Michigan | Big Ten | Michigan St. | 03-OCT-09 | 20-26 | 1 |
| Michigan St. | Big Ten | Michigan | 03-OCT-09 | 26-20 | 1 |
| Minnesota | Big Ten | Syracuse | 05-SEP-09 | 23-20 | 1 |
| Navy | FBS Independent | Air Force | 03-OCT-09 | 16-13 | 1 |
| Navy | FBS Independent | SMU | 17-OCT-09 | 38-35 | 1 |
| North Texas | Sun Belt | Ohio | 12-SEP-09 | 30-31 | 2 |
| Notre Dame | FBS Independent | Washington | 03-OCT-09 | 37-30 | 1 |
| Notre Dame | FBS Independent | Connecticut | 21-NOV-09 | 30-33 | 2 |
| Ohio | Mid-American | North Texas | 12-SEP-09 | 31-30 | 2 |
| Ohio St. | Big Ten | Iowa | 14-NOV-09 | 27-24 | 1 |
| Oregon | Pacific-10 | Arizona | 21-NOV-09 | 44-41 | 2 |
| SMU | Conference USA | Washington St. | 19-SEP-09 | 27-30 | 1 |
| SMU | Conference USA | Navy | 17-OCT-09 | 35-38 | 1 |
| San Jose St. | Western Athletic | Hawaii | 21-NOV-09 | 10-17 | 1 |
| Syracuse | Big East | Minnesota | 05-SEP-09 | 20-23 | 1 |
| Tulane | Conference USA | UTEP | 07-NOV-09 | 45-38 | 1 |
| UTEP | Conference USA | Tulane | 07-NOV-09 | 38-45 | 1 |
| Utah | Mountain West | Air Force | 24-OCT-09 | 23-16 | 1 |
| Vanderbilt | Southeastern | Army | 10-OCT-09 | 13-16 | 1 |
| Wake Forest | Atlantic Coast | Boston College | 26-SEP-09 | 24-27 | 1 |
| Wake Forest | Atlantic Coast | Georgia Tech | 07-NOV-09 | 27-30 | 1 |
| Washington | Pacific-10 | Notre Dame | 03-OCT-09 | 30-37 | 1 |
| Washington St. | Pacific-10 | SMU | 19-SEP-09 | 30-27 | 1 |
| Western Mich. | Mid-American | Buffalo | 24-OCT-09 | 34-31 | 1 |
| Wisconsin | Big Ten | Fresno St. | 12-SEP-09 | 34-31 | 2 |