| 1 | Billy Bitter, North Carolina | So. | UMBC | 05/09/2009 | 8 |
| | Corey Small, Albany (NY) | Sr. | Delaware | 03/06/2009 | 8 |
| | Garrett Billings, Virginia | Sr. | Stony Brook | 02/20/2009 | 8 |
| 4 | Kevin Colleluori, Colgate | Sr. | Holy Cross | 03/07/2009 | 7 |
| | Jim Connolly, Massachusetts | Sr. | Yale | 02/28/2009 | 7 |
| 6 | Ryan Hoff, Notre Dame | Sr. | Ohio St. | 05/03/2009 | 6 |
| | Adam Jones, Canisius | So. | VMI | 04/25/2009 | 6 |
| | Jeff Cohen, Harvard | Fr. | Holy Cross | 04/18/2009 | 6 |
| | Jack Forster, Penn St. | So. | St. John's (NY) | 04/11/2009 | 6 |
| | Chris Boland, Johns Hopkins | Jr. | Virginia | 03/21/2009 | 6 |
| | Bobby Labadini, Providence | Sr. | Wagner | 03/21/2009 | 6 |
| | Jack Mcbride, Princeton | So. | Albany (NY) | 03/20/2009 | 6 |
| | Bryan Neufeld, Siena | Fr. | St. Joseph's | 03/14/2009 | 6 |
| | Trevor Moore, Robert Morris | So. | Presbyterian | 03/10/2009 | 6 |
| | Max Quinzani, Duke | Jr. | Holy Cross | 03/03/2009 | 6 |
| | K.J. Landgraf, Air Force | Sr. | Sacred Heart | 03/01/2009 | 6 |
| | Tom Perini, Lafayette | So. | Wagner | 02/25/2009 | 6 |
| | Dan Kerch, Robert Morris | Sr. | Bellarmine | 02/21/2009 | 6 |
| | Jason Peyer, Army | Sr. | VMI | 02/14/2009 | 6 |
| | Nick Monastero, Colgate | Sr. | Canisius | 02/13/2009 | 6 |
|
Reclassifying
|
| NR | Andrew Athens, Presbyterian | Fr. | Detroit | 04/04/2009 | 7 |
| NR | Zack Greer, Bryant | Sr. | Detroit | 03/20/2009 | 6 |
| NR | Zack Greer, Bryant | Sr. | Sacred Heart | 02/19/2009 | 6 |
| NR | Bryan Kaufmann, Bryant | Sr. | Sacred Heart | 02/19/2009 | 6 |