| 1 | Ned Crotty, Duke | Sr. | North Carolina | 05/17/2009 | 6 |
| | Nick LoCoco, Canisius | So. | VMI | 04/25/2009 | 6 |
| | Ned Crotty, Duke | Sr. | Virginia | 04/11/2009 | 6 |
| | Nick LoCoco, Canisius | So. | Mt. St. Mary's | 04/04/2009 | 6 |
| | Corey Zindel, Marist | So. | VMI | 04/04/2009 | 6 |
| | Shane Koppens, Loyola (MD) | Sr. | Bryant | 03/10/2009 | 6 |
| 7 | Steele Stanwick, Virginia | Fr. | Johns Hopkins | 05/17/2009 | 5 |
| | Brian Caufield, Albany (NY) | So. | Stony Brook | 04/29/2009 | 5 |
| | Brian Caufield, Albany (NY) | So. | Syracuse | 04/17/2009 | 5 |
| | Bobby Karl, Sacred Heart | Sr. | Quinnipiac | 04/11/2009 | 5 |
| | Ryan Duggan, Siena | Jr. | Wagner | 04/04/2009 | 5 |
| | Rob Pannell, Cornell | Fr. | Harvard | 04/04/2009 | 5 |
| | Christian Kellett, Mt. St. Mary's | Fr. | Lafayette | 03/28/2009 | 5 |
| | Austin Winter, Bucknell | Jr. | Holy Cross | 03/28/2009 | 5 |
| | Kyle Hollingsworth, Brown | Sr. | Dartmouth | 03/21/2009 | 5 |
| | Richard Cornetta, Lehigh | Sr. | Army | 03/17/2009 | 5 |
| | Joe Variano, Manhattan | Fr. | Detroit | 02/28/2009 | 5 |
| | Kenny Nims, Syracuse | Sr. | Providence | 02/15/2009 | 5 |
| | Ned Crotty, Duke | Sr. | Bucknell | 02/14/2009 | 5 |