| 1 | Zack Frank, Sacred Heart | Jr. | Villanova | 03/28/2009 | 27 |
| 2 | Drew Adams, Penn St. | Sr. | Hobart | 04/04/2009 | 24 |
| 3 | Sal Barcia, Robert Morris | Jr. | Sacred Heart | 04/25/2009 | 23 |
| 4 | Zack Frank, Sacred Heart | Jr. | Delaware | 04/08/2009 | 22 |
| | Adam Ghitelman, Virginia | So. | Maryland | 03/28/2009 | 22 |
| | Thomas Palesky, Army | So. | Cornell | 02/28/2009 | 22 |
| 7 | T.C. DiBartolo, Mt. St. Mary's | So. | Siena | 04/18/2009 | 21 |
| | Doc Schneider, Massachusetts | Sr. | Hobart | 04/11/2009 | 21 |
| | T.C. DiBartolo, Mt. St. Mary's | So. | Virginia | 02/24/2009 | 21 |
| 10 | Peter Rubin, Wagner | Fr. | Manhattan | 04/15/2009 | 20 |
| | Drew Adams, Penn St. | Sr. | Bucknell | 04/07/2009 | 20 |
| | Jordan Burke, Brown | Sr. | Massachusetts | 03/14/2009 | 20 |
| | Scott Rodgers, Notre Dame | Sr. | Penn St. | 02/22/2009 | 20 |
| | Jimmy Harrison, Holy Cross | Sr. | St. John's (NY) | 02/14/2009 | 20 |