| 1 | Andrew D'Ottavi, St. Joseph's | Fr. | James Madison | 09/11/2009 | 17 |
| 2 | Adrian Foncette, Albany (NY) | So. | Colgate | 09/11/2009 | 16 |
| 3 | Lassi Hurskainen, UNC Asheville | So. | Lipscomb | 09/18/2009 | 15 |
| 4 | Frederick Hall, Quinnipiac | Sr. | St. Francis (NY) | 11/13/2009 | 14 |
| | Patrick Sampson, Loyola Marymount | Sr. | San Francisco | 11/01/2009 | 14 |
| | Mitch Hildebrandt, Oakland | So. | Michigan | 09/30/2009 | 14 |
| | John Fiutowski, Niagara | Sr. | La Salle | 09/06/2009 | 14 |
| 8 | Jed Antoun, Richmond | So. | Massachusetts | 11/06/2009 | 13 |
| | Logan Potter, Stetson | So. | Lipscomb | 10/09/2009 | 13 |
| | Peyton Ford, UNC Greensboro | So. | Wofford | 10/03/2009 | 13 |
| | Rennie Walker, Centenary (LA) | Jr. | William Carey | 09/01/2009 | 13 |
| 12 | Chris Pennock, Rhode Island | Sr. | Charlotte | 11/13/2009 | 12 |
| | Scott Barnum, Gonzaga | So. | Loyola Marymount | 11/06/2009 | 12 |
| | Sean Kelley, George Mason | Sr. | Georgia St. | 10/24/2009 | 12 |
| | Patrick Regna, S.C. Upstate | Sr. | Mercer | 10/10/2009 | 12 |
| | Darius Motazed, St. Francis (PA) | Jr. | Central Conn. St. | 10/02/2009 | 12 |
| | Cody Suppe, UC Riverside | Fr. | Cal St. Northridge | 09/30/2009 | 12 |
| | Patrick Regna, S.C. Upstate | Sr. | Presbyterian | 09/26/2009 | 12 |
| | Tyler Keever, IUPUI | So. | Eastern Ill. | 09/20/2009 | 12 |
| | Ryan Jones, Syracuse | So. | Colgate | 09/07/2009 | 12 |
|
Reclassifying
|
| NR | Victor Tutino, Bryant | Jr. | Robert Morris | 11/01/2009 | 12 |