| 1 | Llyod O'Neill, Barton | Fr. | Chowan | 10/21/2009 | 5 |
| | Dion Peters, Charleston (WV) | So. | Bluefield Col. | 08/27/2009 | 5 |
| 3 | Lamine Traore, Dowling | Sr. | Queens (NY) | 11/06/2009 | 4 |
| | Amr Hailat, S.C. Aiken | So. | Ga. Southwestern | 10/24/2009 | 4 |
| | Jose Batista, Molloy | Sr. | Mercy | 10/06/2009 | 4 |
| | Tyler Reinhart, Cal Poly Pomona | Jr. | Cal St. Dom. Hills | 10/02/2009 | 4 |
| | Ben Everson, West Tex. A&M | Jr. | St. Mary's (TX) | 09/27/2009 | 4 |
| | Niklas Boedts, Wis.-Parkside | So. | Ky. Wesleyan | 09/20/2009 | 4 |
| | Jake Pittroff, Quincy | Jr. | Hannibal-La Grange | 09/17/2009 | 4 |
| | Angel Jose Rodriguez, Goldey-Beacom | Sr. | Chestnut Hill | 09/17/2009 | 4 |