| 1 | Leonado Tillemont, Salem Int'l | Sr. | Findley | 09/09/2009 | 27 |
| 2 | Mark Ferretti, Holy Family | So. | Bloomfield | 10/10/2009 | 22 |
| 3 | Leonado Tillemont, Salem Int'l | Sr. | Wheeling Jesuit | 10/16/2009 | 21 |
| 4 | Leonado Tillemont, Salem Int'l | Sr. | West Va. Tech | 10/04/2009 | 20 |
| 5 | Jared Jacobs, Colo. Christian | Fr. | Mesa St. | 10/16/2009 | 18 |
| 6 | Sean Teepen, Charleston (WV) | Fr. | Lewis | 11/20/2009 | 16 |
| | Leonado Tillemont, Salem Int'l | Sr. | Alderson-Broaddus | 10/07/2009 | 16 |
| | Jared Jacobs, Colo. Christian | Fr. | Fort Lewis | 09/18/2009 | 16 |
| 9 | Steven Alonso, Bloomfield | Jr. | Philadelphia U. | 11/02/2009 | 15 |
| | Jarod Thomas, Adams St. | Fr. | Westminster (UT) | 10/18/2009 | 15 |
| | Amadu Fullah, Salem Int'l | So. | Charleston (WV) | 10/11/2009 | 15 |
| | Joel Johnson, Newberry | So. | S.C. Aiken | 09/30/2009 | 15 |
| | Derek Luptak, Mary | Jr. | Great Falls | 09/26/2009 | 15 |
| | Leonado Tillemont, Salem Int'l | Sr. | Davis & Elkins | 09/19/2009 | 15 |
| 15 | Patrik Ohlsson, St. Rose | So. | Franklin Pierce | 10/10/2009 | 14 |
| | Steven Alonso, Bloomfield | Jr. | Philadelphia U. | 10/03/2009 | 14 |
| | Jared Jacobs, Colo. Christian | Fr. | Metro St. | 10/02/2009 | 14 |
| | Leonado Tillemont, Salem Int'l | Sr. | WV Wesleyan | 09/26/2009 | 14 |
| | Andrew Cairns, Goldey-Beacom | Jr. | Philadelphia U. | 09/22/2009 | 14 |
| | Mickie Holbert, Salem Int'l | So. | Seton Hill | 09/15/2009 | 14 |
|
Reclassifying
|
| NR | Conrad Buechter, Maryville (MO) | Jr. | Mo. Baptist | 08/29/2009 | 15 |