| Division | Name & Institution | Conference | Eligibility Exhausted | Date of Graduation | Sport | Term Expiration | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| II | Bennett Cherry California State University, San Marcos |
California Collegiate Athletic Association | JAN 2027 | ||||
| II | Damian "DJ" Guest, Jr. California State University, Dominguez Hills |
California Collegiate Athletic Association | 2024-25 | 05/2025 | Men's Basketball | JAN 2026 | |
| II | Scott Borgmann, Jr. Wilmington University (Delaware) |
Central Atlantic Collegiate Conference | 2025-26 | 06/2025 | Baseball | JAN 2026 | |
| II | Justin Zavala Bowie State University |
Central Intercollegiate Athletic Association | 2024-25 | 05/2024 | Football | JAN 2026 | |
| II | Cullen Dore Francis Marion University |
Conference Carolinas | 2023-24 | 05/2024 | Men's Cross Country, Men's Track, Outdoor | JAN 2025 | |
| II | Laura Amaya Roberts Wesleyan University |
East Coast Conference | 2024-25 | 05/2024 | Women's Volleyball | JAN 2025 | |
| II | Avery Hellmuth Oklahoma Baptist University |
Great American Conference | 2024-25 | 05/2024 | Women's Volleyball | JAN 2026 | |
| II | Grace Hoeppner Michigan Technological University |
Great Lakes Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | 2025-26 | 05/2025 | Women's Soccer | JAN 2027 | |
| II | Derrick Parker II Grand Valley State University |
Great Lakes Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | 2025-26 | 05/2026 | Football | JAN 2027 | |
| II | Danielle Mabry Rockhurst University |
Great Lakes Valley Conference | 2023-24 | 05/2023 | Women's Lacrosse | JAN 2025 | |
| II | Alexis Montalvo Ashland University |
Great Midwest Athletic Conference | 2023-24 | 05/2024 | Women's Lacrosse | JAN 2025 | |
| II | Dustyn McKenney Western Oregon University |
Great Northwest Athletic Conference | 2024-25 | 06/2025 | Men's Cross Country, Men's Track, Indoor, Men's Track, Outdoor | JAN 2026 | |
| II | Alia Scotka University of West Florida |
Gulf South Conference | 2024-25 | 05/2025 | Women's Golf | JAN 2026 | |
| II | Scout Huffman Texas Woman's University |
Lone Star Conference | 2024-25 | 08/2025 | Women's Basketball | JAN 2026 | |
| II | Theresa Grosbach Missouri Western State University |
Mid-America Intercollegiate Athletics Association | JAN 2027 | ||||
| II | Kara Amos Missouri Southern State University |
Mid-America Intercollegiate Athletics Association | 2023-24 | 05/2024 | Softball | JAN 2025 | |
| II | Addison Courtney Fairmont State University |
Mountain East Conference | 2024-25 | 05/2024 | Men's Wrestling | JAN 2026 | |
| II | Katie Williamson Southern Connecticut State University |
Northeast-10 Conference | 2024-25 | 05/2024 | Women's Basketball | JAN 2025 | |
| II | Eddie Baker The College of Saint Rose |
Northeast-10 Conference | 2023-24 | 05/2024 | Men's Lacrosse | JAN 2025 | |
| II | Davaris Cheeks Concordia University, St. Paul |
Northern Sun Intercollegiate Conference | 2024-25 | 12/2023 | Football | JAN 2025 | |
| II | David Mayser University of Hawaii at Hilo |
Pacific West Conference | 2024-25 | 05/2024 | Men's Soccer | JAN 2025 | |
| II | Haley Gilbert Augusta University |
Peach Belt Conference | 2024-25 | 05/2024 | Women's Cross Country, Women's Track, Outdoor | JAN 2026 | |
| II | Courtney Medwin West Chester University of Pennsylvania |
Pennsylvania State Athletic Conference | 2023-24 | 05/2024 | Women's Lacrosse | JAN 2025 | |
| II | Austin Mondello Colorado Mesa University |
Rocky Mountain Athletic Conference | 2024-25 | 05/2024 | Men's Swimming and Diving | JAN 2025 | |
| II | Alexis Hope Devlin Catawba College |
South Atlantic Conference | 2024-25 | 05/2024 | Women's Track, Indoor, Women's Track, Outdoor | JAN 2026 | |
| II | Haley White Lincoln Memorial University |
South Atlantic Conference | 2024-25 | 05/2025 | Women's Tennis, Field Hockey | JAN 2026 | |
| II | Shani Idlette Clark Atlanta University |
Southern Intercol. Ath. Conf. | 2024-25 | 05/2023 | Women's Tennis | JAN 2025 | |
| II | JJ Hayes Palm Beach Atlantic University |
Sunshine State Conference | 2025-26 | 05/2026 | Men's Basketball | JAN 2026 |